elf cosmetics uk

Autism and MMR Link, Parents Fooled, Follow the Money, Then LISTEN

listenI’ll begin this post by saying that I understand the basics — that many parents of children with autism believe that autism was brought on by vaccines.  And that scientific research has over and over again proven that link does not exist.

Then I watched the Dateline / Matt Lauer interviews and exposé, A Dose of Controversy, about where that suggestion came from, profiling Andrew Wakefield, the doctor/scientist who first suggested that link existed, and who is now hailed a hero by many of those parents who still believe in the connection.  Also interviewed were two more major players in the argument – Brian Deer, a British journalist who has exposed Wakefield over and over again, and Dr. Paul Offit, infectious diseases expert from Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, who has written a book called Autism’s False Prophets which lambasts Wakefield’s work.

Matt Lauer pulled no punches in his questioning of any of the three.  It’s very clear that the worshipping behavior of these parents who believe that somehow Andrew Wakefield represents the second coming is misplaced.  But even more than that – it’s very easy to see how we observers must use the follow the money rule on all three of these men.  Perhaps an even bigger lesson has to do with LISTENING.

But we also must remember in the midst of this — that many studies (I can’t find a number, but it was suggested there were at least dozens) — studying, literally, MILLIONS of children — have proven every time (not just some, but every time) that an autism-vaccine link DOES NOT EXIST.  Even The Lancet, a highly respected medical journal, the one which originally published Andrew Wakefield’s article about that link, has stated that they never would have published it if they had known how Wakefield’s work had been funded (see below.)

Follow the money (FTM) — it’s the rule that helps explain a lot of the “why’s” in healthcare.  Here are examples, as applied to the questions about autism:

FTM explains why Andrew Wakefield would continue asserting that the MMR vaccine causes autism — because he is/was paid in at least two ways to make sure that was clear.  First, he was paid at least $750,000 by a company that developed a measles-only vaccine that could have been used as a substitute for the MMR.  Now, under suspicion for other (unspecified) charges in his native England, he has set up an outpost in Austin, Texas (have to wonder about the wordsmithing there — Austin and Autism) — but is not licensed to practice medicine in the United States.  Parents are paying thousands of dollars to have their children tested for certain gastrointestinal problems possibly related to autism, but it was unclear as to whether any children have actually been helped by Wakefield.  Further, outside of parents talking about how wonderful he is, none seemed to be able to pinpoint exactly why — except that he listens.

(All other doctors of every stripe — please take heed of that — HE LISTENS.)

Brian Deer – his FTM is a bit easier to track.  He is paid to do his investigating and writing, so finding a goldmine like Andrew Wakefield is job security.  It should be noted that Deer also needs the money to defend himself legally. He has been sued a number of times by Wakefield — always unsuccessfully — Deer has always prevailed, able to prove that his allegations about Wakefield were accurate and defensible.

Dr. Paul Offit requires some FTM analysis as well.  Beyond the income from his book where he alleges that parents have been scammed by Wakefield for more than 10 years, he is full-on supportive of vaccines – including the fact that he is the developer-inventor of one vaccine.  So yes, he makes money as the developer of the vaccine, which seems to be unrelated to autism.  Interestingly, he has an expense many would not ever think of — he is forced to pay for bodyguards, because some of those Wakefield supporting parents have threatened his life.

Here are some beliefs I hold, which affect my beliefs about this controversy:

  • I absolutely believe each of these parents who has observed their children well enough to say “She was fine, then she got the vaccine, and something happened.”  I don’t question that for a minute, because I do believe parents are THAT WELL tuned in to their children.
  • I also know human nature well enough to understand why parents cling to any belief that would help them explain something that is otherwise not understandable.  As humans, we all want to assign blame. It’s the reason we can’t cope with problems like Hurricane Katrina, or any other mother nature related catastrophe — because there’s really no one to blame.  By clinging to the vaccine-as-perpetrator, parents have someone to blame, plus the bonus of a hero in Wakefield.  (Plus making Jenny McCarthy a hero — another story for another day.)
  • When people are desperate, like these parents with autistic children, they will go to extremes, even when those extremes don’t make sense.  To so desperately believe in something that has been disproven in so many ways, and to be threatening the life of someone who truly makes sense — these are moves of desperation.

Combining those beliefs, and having done a brief FTM analysis – we have to look at some bigger picture questions, too.  I provide no answers here — I’m just sayin’…

  • So what if Wakefield and all these parents are right?  What if the MMR vaccine DOES trigger something that causes autism?  Maybe it’s not the vaccine itself — maybe the child happened to have eaten something that day, or has another very mild, asymptomatic virus or bacteria in his body — or ?  It could be the vaccine in a combination with something else – I do know a genetic link is being studied, too.
  • Even if there is a link — how does that change things for the parents whose children do have autism?  It doesn’t mean there is a cure.  You can’t subtract the vaccine from their bodies.  So why would parents put so much energy into their hero-making – at the expense of taking time away from their own children to do it?
  • Autism is a “spectrum disorder” — is it possible it’s not just one thing?  Is it possible that even though the symptoms and some of the behaviors are similar, that these children really have different disorders — triggered by different things?  Whose to say that some forms of  ADHD, for example, aren’t really a part of that spectrum?  I know there are many discussions of misdiagnosis among both autism and ADHD diagnoses….

Finally — I believe the bottom line here is the fact that NONE OF THESE PROFESSIONALS get the fact that the passion and desperation fuel this fire and that the people who feel the most maligned (the parents who believe in Wakefield) do so because they feel that he LISTENS.

And that is the bottom line for today’s very long-winded post.  We all need to listen more because listening, then responding appropriately, will lend itself to compromise and understanding — no matter what the controversy.

I’m listening — what can you tell me that will help explain what I don’t understand?

Want more tools and commentary for wise patients?
Sign up for Every Patient’s Advocate email tips
- – - – - – - – - – -
Join Trisha in the Patient Empowerment Forum at About.com
- – - – - – - – - – -
Or link here to empower yourself at EveryPatientsAdvocate.com

7 Responses to “Autism and MMR Link, Parents Fooled, Follow the Money, Then LISTEN”


  1. 1Mark

    FTM.
    Brian Deer made the original complaint against wakefield to the GMC and he has continued write about it even though he is the complainant. how can this be acceptable.

    if you really do want to listen , listen to the parents of the lancet children and Brian Deer in the 1 hour documentary about Brian Deer, perhaps you should review it after you have watched it, it makes uncomfortable viewing.
    “Selective Hearing , Brian deer and the GMC”
    http://www.viddler.com/explore/ziggy/videos/1/

    thank you for asking people to listen, its all we ask.

  2. 2Some Questions

    Which study is more informative? A study by a British GI researcher who examines 12 patients and reports his findings OR a study by a Danish vaccine wholesaler who examines only a medical registry database of hundreds of thousands of children but never examines the actual children?

    When did the number of research subjects determine the quality of a study? When did medical databases become more valued research than examining patient?

    When did the medical establishment recognize that smoking caused lung cancer? About 40 to 50 years after the first research showed there was a link. The link between smoking and lung cancer was obfuscated by years of industry funded research showing no link.

    When did a study that could not find a link equal proving no link exists?

    Why is it ok for vaccine companies to investigate vaccine safety, but it not ok for airlines to investigate air travel safety? Why is it ok for public health officials to promote vaccines, regulate vaccines, and investigate the safety of vaccines and at the time work for vaccine manufactures as consultants?

    By the way, the $750K paid to Dr. Wakefield was for 4 years of work. The $29 million paid to Dr. Offit for his patent rights was for decades of work developing his Rototeq vaccine. Brian Deer’s boss sits on the board of directors of Merck the maker of the MMR vaccine. All good work, if you can get it.

    Why do we assume one side of the debate must be right? Why can’t they all be wrong? If the MMR is shown not to cause autism, does that mean the 13 other childhood vaccines don’t?

    Why do we assume one side of the debate must be wrong? Why can’t they all be right? It might be shown one day that the MMR causes autism when injected to infants with a compromised immune system who are on antibiotics along with other vaccines on the same day, but the study of a medical registry finds no link between the MMR and autism.

  3. 3Marcy

    As an RN with a good deal of experience on this subject, I can tell you what I think vaccines.

    But, I was listening and that actually was not your question. And you have hit the nail on the head.

    According to research published on bmj.coma last week,
    just over half of healthcare workers surveyed say they would not be vaccinated against swine flu because of fears of side effects and doubts about efficacy.

    The response from most “experts” concludes that Doctors and Nurses just need more education to change their minds.

    However, others noted that this really has not worked in the past.

    ” In an accompanying editorial, Rachel Jordan from the University of Birmingham and Andrew Hayward from the UCL Centre for Infectious Disease Epidemiology, highlight that vaccination for healthcare workers is important for their own protection, the protection of their patients and could help to keep the NHS functioning at full capacity during the swine flu pandemic.

    They argue that education and promotional campaigns alone have not been enough to encourage healthcare workers to get vaccinated, “but the additional use of convenient mobile systems, monitoring and feedback systems, and the use of “opt-out” systems (where healthcare workers need to indicate their reasons for not accepting the vaccine) show promise.”

    Some even encourage that healthcare workers who are not vaccinated wear some sort of Marker” ( badge of shame? ) to let people know they have not been vaccinated.

    I have to tell you this is standard stuff from these people.

    Are they listening to what healthcare workers are saying?

    Maybe , but they do not care as they are practicing coercion, not education.

    If this is what they do to healthcare workers, who have the knowledge and education, imagine how they treat “lay people”?

    As a patient advocate, we teach people to look at any medical intervention the same way.

    Do the benefits outweight the risks for each person?

    How can people know this if they are not really given the real benefits verses risks?

    Those Healthcare workers are very clear that from all the research so far, the benefit does not outweight the risk, and they as much as said this.

    So the answer is to keep telling them it does , or to say they are lacking education, or worse to take actions and tactics to get them to do it?

    What would Dr Wakefield do? Hmmm?

    This is why people have become so untrusting of medicine and rightly so.

  4. 4Gail

    To research vaccines that have been recalled, you may go to: http://www.cdc.gov/search.do?queryText=vaccine+recalls&action=search

    There are over 420 recall articles on the CDC Website. Many have die before anything is ever recalled. Please do research and learn all that you can, before injecting anything into your body. Find out all the ingredients and do research on the side effects. The FDA Website has changed the past 6 months, and it does not have the information that use to be on their webiste. I find this very disturbing. The CDC has more information than the FDA Website. Please protect yourself and find out everything about every vaccine you are considering.

  5. 5Michael Kirsch, M.D.

    There is no medical evidence that autism is caused by the MMR or any other vaccine. Some tragedies and adverse events have no explanation, despite the prevailing culture’s obsession to hold someone responsible for every misadventure. Sadly, these legal efforts assume a life of their own and do not lead to a satisfying conclusion for all involved. http://www.MDWhistleblower.blogspot.com

  6. 6Gerardo Rafael

    I picked up on the line about Hurricane Katrina…people needing to blame someone for a natural disaster…let’s not forget that what was appalling about this situation was the lack of a timely response. It was obvious that people needed immediate help and our fearless leader at the time, did not react appropriately. Yet when there were actually NO WEAPONS OF MASS DESTRUCTION, he ball-faced lied to the American public so we would concede going into war – meanwhile billions of dollars have been spent to support this war and who does this money go to? Follow the Money!!! Things have gotten so out of hand where money is concerned that those who have most of it want even more and seem to be willing to do ANYTHING to get it – at the expense of how many lives and limbs??? When are we going to wake up to the fact that we’re being mislead constantly….shown something in the right hand while the left hand is doing something dastardly???? We all get what we deserve for being the sitting ducks we all are….sheep to the slaughter. God Help Us All in the wake of all this corruption!

  7. 7julie petitt

    How about this parents, less worry less about what caused it for our children and more about how to help them. Nothing changes the situation we are in no matter who or what is to blame. Sure, you can sit there and say well, I don’t want it to happen to anyone else, but ultimately, you are, we all are first worried about our own. So lets all get together and hel our children the best we can with what we have! Then we all can say… “WE BEAT YOU!” That…. is better than anything else for all of us. Not the money from the companies we sue… but by the learning we give our children. THAT.. is first with me.

Comments are currently closed.